Oddsbay’s handicapping team is ready for NFL regular season betting, and today we’ve got a play in Sunday’s action between the Pittsburgh Steelers and Atlanta Falcons. Check back every day for more football action!
ATLANTA FALCONS AT PITTSBURGH STEELERS—SEPTEMBER 12, 10 AM PACIFIC
The Pittsburgh Steelers haven’t been a regular season home underdog since 2004, but they’ll be back in that unfamiliar role to start the 2010 NFL campaign hosting the Atlanta Falcons. The reason for the price is obvious—the Steelers will be without their starting quarterback, Ben Roethlisberger and linesmakers have factored that into the pointspread. The Steelers won both of their 2004 spots as home underdogs outright, and we think they’ll do the same thing here.
The line on this game opened with Pittsburgh a +2’ point home dog, and that line is still available at a number of sportsbooks. Other books have this game at +2 or even +1, but that’s not indicative of a flood of money coming in on Pittsburgh. Time for a football handicapping theory lesson—the number 3 is what we refer to as a ‘key number’ due to the large percentage of games that end up with a 3 point margin of victory for one team or the other. 7 is also a key number, though a less significant one, and you should also pay attention to multiples of 3 and 7, as well as prices like 10 and 13. That being said, 3 is the most important ‘key number’ and especially in the NFL. The exact percentage varies from year to year, but in the longterm right around 20% of all NFL games land on the key number of 3. For that reason, a line differential between +1 and +2’ isn’t as significant as one between +3 and +3’—in the latter example, the key number clearly comes into play.
It’s doubtful that this price will go any higher than +2’ for that reason—sports betting pros often jump at the chance to take any game with a price at or just above the ‘key number’ of 3. If it does, this is an even stronger play. An important consideration in all sports handicapping is understanding public perception and how it influences how games are priced, and this is a clear example of that phenomenon. The general public—or ‘squares’ in betting lingo—are focused on the Roethlisberger suspension, and the pointspread has been adjusted accordingly. And as in most cases when a team will play without a high profile starter, the adjustment is an overcompensation relative to the missing player’s true value.
There’s an interesting phenomena that you see in all team sports when a key player is injured. While a long term/season ending injury or suspension can be catastrophic, teams usually respond favorably to short term absences, particularly those of a definite duration. In fact, one of my favorite betting situations is to play *on* teams missing a key starter in the short term. Frequently, it produces very strong betting value for a couple of reasons, not the least of which is the aforementioned overcompensation in the price. In addition, teams usually work hard to ‘pick up the slack’ for the missing player.
In Pittsburgh’s case, this concept should be especially strong. Unlike a midseason injury, they’ve known the Roethlisberger suspension was coming and spent the entire preseason preparing to deal with it. On the surface, it may seem like that was dealt a blow with the injury to Byron Leftwich, but that opens the door for the younger and more mobile Dennis Dixon. Dixon is likely the Steelers’ quarterback of the future, and has received a lot of playing time in the preseason. His teammates and coaches have a lot of confidence in Dixon, and in a roundabout way this could be a better situation for the Steelers than if the more experienced but less athletic Leftwich was at the helm. Leftwich was clearly a temporary fix, but Dixon is a better fit in the team’s longterm plans.
Furthermore, there’s any number of questions about just how important Roethlisberger is to the Steelers’ future—immediate and longterm. During ‘Big Ben’s’ last controversy, when he was accused of sexual assault by a Nevada hotel worker in 2009, the team rallied around their quarterback—even re-electing him as one of four team captains. That didn’t happen this year, and for the first time since 2007 Roethlisberger was not chosen as a captain by his teammates. At the very least, he’s got a lot of ‘fence mending’ to do. Worst case scenario, this repeated pattern of behavior could have caused teammates to conclude that he’s not the leader they thought he was. He’s not getting any votes of confidence from the coaching staff either—on Monday, coach Mike Tomlin refused to comment when asked if Roethlisberger would get the starting job back upon serving his suspension. The ‘no comment’ was a dramatic change in prevailing opinion, as everything Tomlin had said until now strongly suggested that whomever started the season at quarterback was just filling the position until Roethlisberger’s return.
With or without Roethlisberger, the Steelers are still a very good team. They return the #5 total defense from 2009, and it should be even stronger this year with Troy Polamalu and safety Aaron Smith back in the lineup. Polamalu’s return from injury is potentially huge—he’s not only a fearsome pass rusher but the emotional leader of the defense. Plugging him back into a defense that was #2 in sacks and #3 against the run without him could return the unit to dominance.
On offense, Dixon could make some mistakes due to inexperience but has considerable upside. Most importantly, he’s not going to be put into a position where he has to win games on his own. Pittsburgh has a solid rushing game to work with, led by Rashard Medenhall. He’s not a household name among casual fans, but he’s already rated by experts as one of the top ten running backs in the NFL and his stock should rise as the season progresses. All Dixon will be asked to do is minimize mistakes and let the running game and defense carry the load.
Finally, while Atlanta is pretty solid on offense with quarterback Matt Ryan and running back Michael Turner, their defense is vulnerable. The Steelers should have a significant size advantage ‘in the trenches’ and Dixon will have a good margin for error when he takes to the air against a Falcons secondary that ranked #28 in the NFL a year ago. No matter what they eventually decide to do upon Roethlisberger’s return, they’ve made it a goal to go no worse than 2-2 in his absence. With a tough road game at Tennessee next week and a home game against Baltimore on October 3, this game and the September 26 road game at Tampa Bay are essential. Steelers have won 3 of the last 4 meetings straight up, and we look for them to open the 2010 season with a home victory here. The general public is more worried about Roethlisberger’s absence than the Steelers are, and they’re the ones who’ll play—and win—this game.
PLAY PITTSBURGH STEELERS +2’ OVER ATLANTA FALCONS







